Biden White House Leans Toward Releasing Information About Trump And Jan. 6 Attack, Setting Off Legal And Political Showdown

The White House is leaning toward releasing information to Congress about what Donald Trump and his aides were doing during the Jan. 6 attack on the U.S. Capitol despite the former president’s objections — a decision that could have significant political and legal ramifications.

Was the attack on the U.S. Capitol an attempted coup? The Washington Post The Washington Post> The Washington Post See more videos "> See more videos > > > > > What to watch next
  • Smerconish: Despite what we've learned, Trump can beat Biden in 2024 Smerconish: Despite what we've learned, Trump can beat Biden in 2024>

    Smerconish: Despite what we've learned, Trump can beat Biden in 2024

    CNN Logo CNN
  • NASA's asteroid hunter Lucy soars into sky NASA's asteroid hunter Lucy soars into sky>

    NASA's asteroid hunter Lucy soars into sky

    Associated Press Logo Associated Press
  • One Texas deputy killed, two injured in Houston shooting One Texas deputy killed, two injured in Houston shooting>

    One Texas deputy killed, two injured in Houston shooting

    MSNBC Logo MSNBC
  • Biden admin. seeks to get IRS access for bank accounts over $600 Biden admin. seeks to get IRS access for bank accounts over $600>

    Biden admin. seeks to get IRS access for bank accounts over $600

    CNN Logo CNN
  • Clyburn: 'These are not Joe Biden problems. These are global problems.' Clyburn: 'These are not Joe Biden problems. These are global problems.'>

    Clyburn: 'These are not Joe Biden problems. These are global problems.'

    CNN Logo CNN
  • HOUSTON, TEXAS - AUGUST 23: A student takes notes during instruction at the Xavier Academy on August 23, 2021 in Houston, Texas. In-person classroom sessions are resuming and schools around Houston are requiring mask mandates, keeping in accordance with CDC guidelines. Harris County Judge Lina Hidalgo has gone against Gov. Greg Abbott's statewide ban on mask mandates and has issued an order that requires face coverings to be worn in schools. All staff and faculty at Xavier Academy have been vaccinated and 90% of students in attendance have also been vaccinated. (Photo by Brandon Bell/Getty Images) HOUSTON, TEXAS - AUGUST 23: A student takes notes during instruction at the Xavier Academy on August 23, 2021 in Houston, Texas. In-person classroom sessions are resuming and schools around Houston are requiring mask mandates, keeping in accordance with CDC guidelines. Harris County Judge Lina Hidalgo has gone against Gov. Greg Abbott's statewide ban on mask mandates and has issued an order that requires face coverings to be worn in schools. All staff and faculty at Xavier Academy have been vaccinated and 90% of students in attendance have also been vaccinated. (Photo by Brandon Bell/Getty Images)>

    Teachers told to include books with 'opposing' views of Holocaust

    CNN Logo CNN
  • Covid has killed more police than gunfire since pandemic began Covid has killed more police than gunfire since pandemic began>

    Covid has killed more police than gunfire since pandemic began

    CNN Logo CNN
  • 'Words certainly matter': Psaki on watchdog complaint against her 'Words certainly matter': Psaki on watchdog complaint against her>

    'Words certainly matter': Psaki on watchdog complaint against her

    CNN Logo CNN
  • GOP pushing to probe Transportation Secretary Buttigieg over supply chain crisis GOP pushing to probe Transportation Secretary Buttigieg over supply chain crisis>

    GOP pushing to probe Transportation Secretary Buttigieg over supply chain crisis

    FOX News Logo FOX News
  • NASA launches Lucy spacecraft on 12-year quest to explore asteroids NASA launches Lucy spacecraft on 12-year quest to explore asteroids>

    NASA launches Lucy spacecraft on 12-year quest to explore asteroids

    TODAY Logo TODAY
  • Myanmar junta leader excluded from top summit Myanmar junta leader excluded from top summit>

    Myanmar junta leader excluded from top summit

    Reuters Logo Reuters
  • Former President Clinton remains hospitalized after infection Former President Clinton remains hospitalized after infection>

    Former President Clinton remains hospitalized after infection

    CBS News Logo CBS News
  • Fatal stabbing of British lawmaker David Amess declared a terrorist incident Fatal stabbing of British lawmaker David Amess declared a terrorist incident>

    Fatal stabbing of British lawmaker David Amess declared a terrorist incident

    CBS News Logo CBS News
  • Democrats struggle to reduce President Biden’s spending plan Democrats struggle to reduce President Biden’s spending plan>

    Democrats struggle to reduce President Biden’s spending plan

    CBS News Logo CBS News
  • FDA advisers back booster shots for Johnson & Johnson recipients FDA advisers back booster shots for Johnson & Johnson recipients>

    FDA advisers back booster shots for Johnson & Johnson recipients

    CBS News Logo CBS News
  • Bill Clinton is ‘doing fine’ after being admitted to hospital, Biden says Bill Clinton is ‘doing fine’ after being admitted to hospital, Biden says>

    Bill Clinton is ‘doing fine’ after being admitted to hospital, Biden says

    TODAY Logo TODAY
> > > > >
  • Smerconish: Despite what we've learned, Trump can beat Biden in 2024 Smerconish: Despite what we've learned, Trump can beat Biden in 2024> Smerconish: Despite what we've learned, Trump can beat Biden in 2024 Michael Smerconish asks if Democrats should worry less about Trump stealing the 2024 election and more about him actually winning. Biden's approval ratings have ebbed as his presidency faces many big issues including the Delta variant, roadblocks to his congressional agenda, the chaotic withdrawal from Afghanistan and inflation. CNN Logo CNN
  • NASA's asteroid hunter Lucy soars into sky NASA's asteroid hunter Lucy soars into sky> NASA's asteroid hunter Lucy soars into sky A NASA spacecraft named Lucy has rocketed into the sky with diamonds on a 12-year quest to explore a record-setting eight asteroids. Lucy blasted off before dawn on Saturday from Cape Canaveral, Florida. (Oct. 16) Associated Press Logo Associated Press
  • One Texas deputy killed, two injured in Houston shooting One Texas deputy killed, two injured in Houston shooting> One Texas deputy killed, two injured in Houston shooting One deputy was killed and two injured in what police are calling an "ambush" by a man with a rifle outside of a bar in Houston. A potential suspect is in custody and a search is underway for another. MSNBC Logo MSNBC
UP NEXT UP NEXT

Trump has said he will cite “executive privilege” to block information requests from the House select committee investigating the events of that day, banking on a legal theory that has successfully allowed presidents and their aides to avoid or delay congressional scrutiny for decades, including during the Trump administration.

Loading...

Load Error

But President Biden’s White House plans to err on the side of disclosure given the gravity of the events of Jan. 6, according to two people familiar with discussions who, like others, spoke on the condition of anonymity to describe the private talks.

In response to questions about White House deliberations over what information to release, Biden spokesman Michael J. Gwin said the president views the attack on the Capitol as “a dark stain on our country’s history” and is “deeply committed to ensuring that something like that can never happen again, and he supports a thorough investigation.”

>[Can Trump use executive privilege to stall the Jan. 6 investigation?]

Members of the investigative committee argue that Trump no longer enjoys the protection of executive privilege, encouraging the White House to push aside institutional concerns about sharing information with Congress and aid the panel in an investigation focused on what Democrats and a handful of Republicans have called an assault on democracy.

“It’s not really relevant because there’s no president involved — there’s no such thing as a former president’s executive privilege,” said Rep. Jamie B. Raskin (D-Md.), a committee member who teaches constitutional law. “That’s extremely dilute and not really relevant.”

What Trump was doing while the attack was occurring and who he was speaking with are among the big unanswered questions concerning the assault on the Capitol.

The debate over the validity of his executive privilege claims comes as the committee is moving into a new, more aggressive phase of its investigation. Having requested material from telecom and social media companies and the White House — and receiving some response — it is now looking at how best to compel testimony and documents from those reluctant to participate.

Committee Chairman Bennie G. Thompson (D-Miss.) said this week that his panel will soon issue subpoenas to witnesses and organizations, adding that the committee has started scheduling closed-door testimony with cooperative witnesses. On Thursday night, the committee issued subpoenas to former White House chief of staff Mark Meadows, former deputy chief of staff Dan Scavino, former Pentagon official Kash Patel and longtime Trump adviser Stephen K. Bannon. The committee is seeking documents as well as testimony from the four men.

>[House Jan. 6 committee issues subpoenas for Trump aides and advisers, including Meadows and Scavino]

Trump has derided the committee’s work as partisan and is promising to fight its effort to collect information and testimony related to the attack.

“The highly partisan, Communist-style ‘select committee’ has put forth an outrageously broad records request that lacks both legal precedent and legislative merit,” Trump spokesman Taylor Budowich said in a statement. “Executive privilege will be defended, not just on behalf of President Trump and his administration, but also on behalf of the Office of the President of the United States and the future of our nation.”

>[Jan. 6 committee faces unprecedented choice of whether to call Republican lawmakers to testify]

In response to the House panel’s request, the National Archives has already identified hundreds of pages of documents from the Trump White House relevant to its inquiry. As required by statute, the material is being turned over to the Biden White House and to Trump’s lawyers for review.

The committee’s Aug. 25 letter to the National Archives was both sweeping and detailed, asking for “all documents and communications within the White House on January 6, 2021, relating in any way” to the events of that day. They include examining whether the White House or Trump allies worked to delay or halt the counting of electoral votes and whether there was discussion of impeding the peaceful transfer of power.

The letter asked for call logs, schedules and meetings for a large group, including Trump’s adult children, son-in-law and senior adviser Jared Kushner and first lady Melania Trump as well as a host of aides and advisers, such as his attorney Rudolph W. Giuliani.

>[House Jan. 6 committee seeks information from tech giants regarding attack on Capitol, attempts to overturn election]

The committee has focused, in part, on seeking information about whether the Trump White House and members of Congress played any role in encouraging the demonstrations, which interrupted the constitutionally mandated certification of electoral votes and unleashed a series of violent confrontations with the U.S. Capitol Police.

So far, more than 650 people have been charged with crimes in connection with the violent demonstrations that delayed that vote. Many were charged with obstructing a federal procedure and with knowingly entering or remaining in a restricted building. Documents and testimony could show whether White House officials and members of Congress encouraged or supported those actions, congressional staffers said.

White House documents requested by the panel are identified by National Archives personnel and then sent to Biden and Trump lawyers. The first tranche was sent out Aug. 31, according to a person familiar with the transfer.

Trump has 30 days after the delivery of the documents to decide whether to object to their release, according to the statute. Even if he opposes turning them over, the Biden White House has decision-making authority and can release them, over Trump’s objections, after an additional 60 days has elapsed. Trump’s remaining option would be to go to court to try to halt the release, legal advisers said.

While Trump has struck a defiant tone, his options may be limited if Biden decides to hand over the information the former president says should be protected, according to several legal experts — including those who have reviewed similar requests in the past.

“The law we have is not favorable to the former president,” said Bob Bauer, who served as White House counsel under President Barack Obama. “A former president has a chance to review the materials, to raise issues of privilege and if the former and the current presidents cannot reach some agreement, to take the dispute to the courts.”

Bauer added that while an inquiry into a former president is unique, legal precedents suggest disclosure of the information Congress is seeking.

“The circumstances here — the former president acting at the time in his capacity as a candidate seeking to challenge his defeat at the polls — make this uphill battle much, much tougher,” he said.

>[Donald McGahn tells House panel about Trump’s bid to undermine Mueller probe]

Norm Eisen, a former Obama administration official who advised the first House impeachment inquiry of Trump, said the former president’s power to assert executive privilege has weakened since he left the White House.

“The executive privilege stonewalling that Trump used while he was in office won’t work anymore,” Eisen said, noting that the current president — not the former — has the real decision-making power.

A former federal judge who worked on executive privilege issues in the Reagan White House and the George H.W. Bush Justice Department pointed out that privilege requests do not typically attempt to shield information about potential wrongdoing.

“With a few notable exceptions, the historical practice has been for Presidents to avoid asserting Executive Privilege to protect from disclosure information that suggests wrongdoing or potential wrongdoing by a President and/or his advisers,” J. Michael Luttig, a former U.S. federal judge, said in an email.

Several cases involving requests for tapes and other records from the Nixon White House provide precedent for release of presidential records when requested by Congress or government agencies.

In 1977, the Supreme Court in Nixon v. Administrator of General Services rejected Nixon’s privilege claims about White House tapes and documents, embracing the idea that executive privilege “is not for the benefit of the President as an individual, but for the benefit of the Republic.”

Legal experts also pointed to recent private talks involving Trump officials and Congress that could provide a path to a resolution that does not involve going to court. They cite the negotiations that occurred between lawyers for Trump, the Justice Department and the Senate Judiciary Committee investigating claims that a Trump Justice Department official, Jeffrey Clark, had sought to deploy department resources after the election to back Trump’s claims of massive voting fraud.

>[What Rosen told U.S. senators: Trump applied ‘persistent’ pressure to get Justice to discredit election]

In the end, the Biden Justice Department waived executive privilege, and two of Trump’s top former Justice Department officials, Jeffrey Rosen and Richard Donoghue, sat for interviews with the Senate Judiciary Committee, providing detailed accounts of what happened during the post-election period.

The decisions Biden and Trump make about the current records and interview requests will be momentous, said Jonathan Turley, a professor at George Washington University who has written about the protection of White House documents and previously argued that Democrats’ impeachment efforts against Trump were a misguided use of congressional power.

“There is an unbroken tradition of deference by the incumbent presidents to their predecessors,” Turley said. “In the past, incumbent presidents would generally support their predecessors in restricting access, despite partisan differences. It appears we may be poised here to shatter that tradition.”

Source : https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/biden-white-house-leans-toward-releasing-information-about-trump-and-jan-6-attack-setting-off-legal-and-political-showdown/ar-AAOKhEU

6317
Filed Under: MSN
Biden White House leans toward releasing information about Trump and Jan. 6 attack, setting off legal and political showdown

Source:MSN

Biden White House leans toward releasing information about Trump and Jan. 6 attack, setting off legal and political showdown

Biden will not assert executive privilege to stop investigators getting hold of Jan. 6 documents

Source:Daily Mail

Biden will not assert executive privilege to stop investigators getting hold of Jan. 6 documents

House Jan. 6 committee issues subpoenas for Trump aides and advisers, including Meadows and Scavino

Source:Washington Post

House Jan. 6 committee issues subpoenas for Trump aides and advisers, including Meadows and Scavino